Judge


 * You may be looking for this judge's younger brother, who's also a judge.

"Judge"

- The law is the end product of many years of history... the fruit of human knowledge! Like a gem, polished to a gleam through trials... and errors. It is this fruit we receive, and pass on, and face in our time. And it is always changing, growing. Nurturing it is our task as human beings.

The "judge" presides over most of Phoenix Wright and Apollo Justice's trials.

Career
"Judge"

- I've seen quite a few things in my many years on the bench. And in all that time, I've finally learned this one thing. Each case is different, and takes place in its own world, if you will. In order to fully understand that world, first we have to immerse ourselves in it completely.

The judge has presided over several notable trials in his many years in the courtroom. This account begins with the trial of Mack Rell in what would come to be known as the second KG-8 Incident, a trial that introduced the judge to then-rookie prosecutor Miles Edgeworth.

The second KG-8 Incident

 * Main article: Turnabout Reminiscence

"Miles Edgeworth"

- Objection! Your Hon--

"Judge"

- I cannot allow you to make an objection.

"Miles Edgeworth"

- What!? Your Honor... I'm really sorry, but...  I cannot allow you to not allow me to make an objection!

"Judge"

- Egads! I've been overruled!?

In 2011, the judge presided over a trial that would end some eras and begin others. When Mack Rell was arrested for murder, he claimed to be the Great Thief Yatagarasu. However, when prosecutor Byrne Faraday brought forth condemning evidence against him in court, Rell suddenly changed his story, accusing Faraday of being the Yatagarasu and the one who had sent him to commit the murder. In light of these events, the judge suspended the trial to make way for a replacement for Faraday: a new prosecutor named Miles Edgeworth. The judge then headed for the restroom. While he was there, he looked out the window, across the courtyard of the District Court, to the 3rd floor hallway. Although he did not see anyone, he did hear what sounded like a gunshot, but promptly forgot about it.

As the judge returned to his bench to restart the trial, Faraday and Rell were both found murdered. The judge remembered what he had seen in the washroom and accused Detective Dick Gumshoe of the murder, testifying about the gunshot he had heard. However, Edgeworth looked into Gumshoe's surveillance job and determined that much of the judge's testimony was built on a number of misunderstandings on his part. Firstly, Gumshoe was, in fact, merely sitting and eating on a bench underneath the window with Kay Faraday, invisible to the judge. Edgeworth also discovered that the sound the judge had heard was just Kay attempting to startle Gumshoe by popping a balloon. Gumshoe was eventually cleared of all charges thanks to Edgeworth's efforts, although the true culprit, who had used another fake gunshot to create an alibi, managed to escape.

Murder at the university

 * Main article: Turnabout Memories

Phoenix Wright returns

 * Main article: The First Turnabout

The Mia Fey murder case

 * Main article: Turnabout Sisters

Death of a star

 * Main article: Turnabout Samurai

Edgeworth on trial

 * Main article: Turnabout Goodbyes

Murder of a detective

 * Main article: Rise from the Ashes

An amnesiac Wright

 * Main article: The Lost Turnabout

Maya Fey on trial again

 * Main article: Reunion, and Turnabout

Tragedy at the circus

 * Main article: Turnabout Big Top

"Judge"

- Enough of these childish outbursts, Mr. Curls! Who do you think you are?

A deadly rivalry

 * Main article: Farewell, My Turnabout

Murder at a restaurant

 * Main article: Recipe for Turnabout

The death of Elise Deauxnim

 * Main article: Bridge to the Turnabout

"Phoenix Wright"

- Did the judge take smart pills at the last recess?

For the trial of Iris in the murder of Elise Deauxnim, the judge's younger brother oversaw the the first half of the trial due to Edgeworth's machinations. However, the older brother soon returned for the second half due to the younger brother falling ill.

The end of an era

 * Main article: Turnabout Succession

A fallen legend on trial

 * Main article: Turnabout Trump

Death of a mobster's doctor

 * Main article: Turnabout Corner

Smuggling and murder

 * Main article: Turnabout Serenade

A case of art, journalism and magic

 * Main article: Turnabout Succession

For the trial of Vera Misham in the murder of Drew Misham, the video cameras installed for the trial of the new Jurist System seemed to make the judge nervous, but he handled the case normally and even seemed to still have some respect for Kristoph Gavin despite the latter's deeds. The verdict was then decided by the jurists.

Personality
"Phoenix Wright"

- (For the love of all things good, Your Honor, have some spine... For my sake...)

The judge is naïve and gullible, but he is said to give the correct verdict without fail. He tends to change his mind very easily, a trait that Phoenix Wright often uses to his advantage. However, he is also very easily wooed by female witnesses such as Dahlia Hawthorne, which has almost allowed guilty female witnesses to be let off the hook several times. It often seems that the judge is more likely to side with the prosecution than the defense and to prefer Miles Edgeworth over Phoenix Wright, but this ultimately does not affect his verdict. He also has a tendency to try to take credit for the work that the attorneys did, which annoyed both Wright and Mia Fey.

The judge is often portrayed as a bit absent-minded and hard of hearing. For example, he has, on at least one occasion, wasted an entire day searching for his dentures only to realize they were in his mouth all along. This absent-mindedness has led to many comical occurrences in the courtroom. In addition, the judge sometimes finds it hard to follow what people are saying, very rarely understanding what Godot says. The judge's brother often criticizes him for not studying hard enough, advice that he took to heart only relatively recently. Nevertheless, the judge occasionally shows signs of deep wisdom.

The judge is very out of touch with technology. For example, he is known not to know the meaning of e-mail or computers, and he refers to old-fashioned things such as the gramophone. He also has never heard of nail polish, leaving him puzzled as to why his wife's nails are red.

The judge often lets his fear of certain people get to him. He is horribly afraid of Franziska von Karma and always gives in to her, to the point of forgetting that he has more authority than she does. His fear of one witness, Furio Tigre, forced him to hide under his stand every time Tigre shouted.

Whenever he is stressed, excited or speaks too much too quickly, he has a tendency to bite his tongue. Following the Cohdopian Embassy murder case, the judge considered teaming up with a baliff and becoming a lawyer, but he decided to keep his current job.

The judge can apparently speak Spanish.

Name
The judge's real name is never revealed, much like Valant Gramarye, Bikini, the judge's younger brother, the Gatewater bellboy, "Director Hotti/Hickfield" and Calisto Yew/Shih-na. Phoenix Wright once received the judge's business card, but couldn't read his signature.

Development

 * Until Gyakuten Kenji 2, the judge had appeared in all Ace Attorney games to date. In fact, after Gumshoe, Wright and Edgeworth, the judge has appeared in the most cases.

Ultimate Marvel vs. Capcom 3
The judge appears in the fighting game Ultimate Marvel vs. Capcom 3 as one of Phoenix Wright's Level 1 Hyper Combos during "Courtroom Mode", Nightmare Judge, in which a shadowy giant version of himself (similar to his appearance in Wright's nightmare in The Lost Turnabout) appears while saying, "Order in the court!" He then smashes his gavel down on Wright and his opponent while saying, "Objection overruled!" While both battling characters are knocked down by this, only Wright's opponent takes damage, although Wright is knocked out of "Courtroom Mode" back to "Investigative Mode".

References to other media
During Bridge to the Turnabout, Godot says to the judge, "Mr. Trite's words are the milk and you are the spoon, Your Honor." The judge, misunderstanding Godot's unusual metaphor, protests, "I-I'm a spoon!? I'm no spoony bard, I'll have you know!" "Spoony bard" is a reference to the notorious line from the English localizations of Final Fantasy IV, in which Tellah refers to Edward Chris von Muir as a "spoony bard", notable as it arose from the work of the translator of both Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney and Final Fantasy IV, Alexander O. Smith.