Ace Attorney Wiki
mNo edit summary
(Removed redundant repetition)
Tag: Visual edit
 
(154 intermediate revisions by 34 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
{{Case Tab|The Adventure of the Great Departure}}
{{JReleased|u}}
 
  +
{{Released}}
 
{{CaseData
 
{{CaseData
|image = AoGD_Title_Card.png{{!}}300px
+
|theme = gaa
|date = Nov. 22, 1899
+
|image = AoGD Title Card.png
  +
|release = ''[[The Great Ace Attorney: Adventures]]'' release
  +
|japanese = ''大いなる旅立ちの冒険'' (''Ōinaru Tabidachi no Bōken'')
  +
|type = Violent death
  +
|date = Friday, Nov. 22
  +
|time = Tuesday, Nov. 19; 2:00 p.m.
  +
|victim = [[John Wilson]]
 
|cause = Asphyxiation caused by [[curare]]{{tt|*|initially thought to be blood loss from gunshot wound}}
 
|chars = [[Yujin Mikotoba]] <br> [[Susato Mikotoba]] <br> [[Aido Nosa]]
  +
|locations = Defendants' Antechamber 5
  +
|evidence = {{EvidenceGAA-1}}
 
|court = 2
 
|court = 2
|judge = Seishirou Jigoku
+
|judge = [[Seishiro Jigoku]]
|defense = [[Ryūnosuke Naruhodō]]
+
|defense =
  +
* [[Ryunosuke Naruhodo]]
|assistants = [[Kazuma Asōgi]]{{tt|*|co-counsel}}
+
* [[Kazuma Asogi]]{{tt|*|co-counsel}}
 
|prosecutor = [[Taketsuchi Auchi]]
 
|prosecutor = [[Taketsuchi Auchi]]
|defendant = [[Ryūnosuke Naruhodō]]
+
|defendant = Ryunosuke Naruhodo
|victim = [[John Watson]]
+
|charge = Murder
|time = November 19, 1899
+
|verdict = Not Guilty
 
|witnesses = [[Satoru Hosonaga]]{{tt|*|not cross-examined}} <br> [[Kyurio Korekuta]] <br> [[Iyesa Nosa]] <br> [[Jezaille Brett]]{{tt|!|arrested}}
|cause = Poisoning caused by curare{{tt|*|Initially thought to be blood loss from the gunshot wound}}
 
  +
|index = 59
|witnesses = [[Satoru Hosonaga]]{{tt|*|not cross-examined}} <br>[[Sanmon Sonohigurashi]] <br>[[Taizou Uzukumaru]] <br>[[Jezail Brett]]{{tt|*|Put on trial in Hong Kong}}
 
  +
|prevna = ''[[Turnabout Time Traveler]]''
|locations = [[Supreme Court Defendant Lobby No. 5]]
 
  +
|preveu = ''Turnabout Time Traveler''
|evidence = School Badge <br> Watson's Autopsy Report <br> Photograph of the Victim <br> Waiter's Business Card <br> Photograph of the Crime Scene <br> Watson's Medical Report <br> Photograph of the Handbag <br> Bottle of Carbonated Water <br> Jezail's Report <br> Beefsteak Dish
 
  +
}}
|chars = [[Yūjin Mikotoba]] <br> [[Susato Mikotoba]]}}
 
  +
{{Quote|Ryunosuke Naruhodo|I won't deny that I'm no expert. I'm just a student. And one who could arguably study harder, too. But standing here now in our Supreme Court, there is one thing that I feel very strongly: A country that fails to uphold the truth in its justice system is a country with no future at all.}}
{{Quote|Ryūnosuke Naruhodō|T... The.. The acting attorney for the accused. F-For this trial, is... M-m-me. Ryūnosuke Naruhodō!}}'''''Episode 1: The Adventure of the Great Departure''''' is the first episode of the game [[Dai Gyakuten Saiban: Naruhodō Ryūnosuke no Bōken|''Dai Gyakuten Saiban: Naruhodō Ryūnosuke no Bōken'']] and follows [[Ryūnosuke Naruhodō]]'s first appearance in court. In his first trial, Ryūnosuke is tried for the murder of a British professor, [[John Watson| Doctor John H. Watson]], despite having no knowledge of law. Ryūnosuke Naruhodō, [[Kazuma Asōgi]], [[Taketsuchi Auchi]], [[Satoru Hosonaga]], [[Yūjin Mikotoba]], [[Susato Mikotoba]], [[Sanmon Sonohigurashi]], [[Taizou Uzukumaru]], and [[Jezail Brett]] all make their debuts in this episode.
 
   
  +
'''''Episode 1: The Adventure of the Great Departure''''' is the first episode of the game ''[[The Great Ace Attorney: Adventures]]''. In late 19th century [[Japan]], during a turbulent time of increasing Western influence on Japanese culture, the stage is set for an international incident. [[John Wilson]], a visiting professor from the [[United Kingdom]], is shot in the restaurant [[La Carneval]], and [[Ryunosuke Naruhodo]], a Japanese university student, is caught red-handed holding a gun. With the Anglo-Japanese Treaty of Friendship and Navigation having just been signed, the Japanese government sees this murder of a British citizen on their soil as a threat to continued good relations between the two island nations. As such, Naruhodo is sent to the [[Supreme Court of Judicature]] to stand in a closed [[trial]], surrounded by military and government officials. Standing by his side is his best friend, [[Kazuma Asogi]], who intends to represent him as his lawyer, but plans change when Naruhodo is informed of the risk that Asogi is taking by taking this case.
Out of all tutorial episodes in the ''[[Ace Attorney]]'' games, ''The Adventure of the Great Departure'' is the longest of all the games, consisting of three [[trial]] segments.
 
   
  +
This episode serves as an introduction not only to the general mechanics and conventions of the ''[[Ace Attorney]]'' series, but also to aspects specific to the setting of ''[[The Great Ace Attorney Chronicles]]''. For example, Wilson's gun is never mentioned to have been examined and the player is unable to do so themselves due to the firearm not appearing in the [[court record]]; this is due to technology in the game's setting being insufficient to perform a ballistics test. In a modern setting like in other ''Ace Attorney'' games, such a test would have immediately proven that the gun held by Naruhodo was not the one used to shoot Wilson. Additionally, it is the longest introductory episode in the series, consisting of three trial segments.
==Crime==
 
[[File:John_H_Watsons_Crime_Scene.png|thumb|left|Watson's body slumped over in his chair.]]
 
At dinner time in the western restaurant, La Quantos, a gunshot rang through the establishment. All of the patrons looked to see a body of a deceased English gentleman. As the authorities arrive, a young man is found holding a gun and was standing in front of the victim.
 
   
  +
==Acts and chapters==
==Ryūnosuke's Trial==
 
  +
{| class="wikitable"
  +
!Act
  +
!Chapter
  +
|-
  +
| rowspan="2" | "Trial, Part 1"
  +
| "Opening"
  +
|-
  +
| "Trial Start"
  +
|-
  +
| rowspan="2" | "Trial, Part 2"
  +
|"Recess"
  +
|-
  +
|"Miss Brett's Appearance"
  +
|-
  +
| rowspan="2" | "Trial, Part 3"
  +
|"Susato's Sudden Entrance"
  +
|-
  +
|"Conclusion"
  +
|}
   
  +
==Timeline==
=== Before the Trial ===
 
  +
{{sub-timeline}}
Three days after the murder, the suspect, [[Ryuunosuke Naruhodō|Ryuunosuke Naruhodo]], is waiting for his trial to begin, awaiting his fate to be decided by the court. One of the bailiffs called him a murderer. His friend and defense attorney, [[Kazuma Asōgi|Kazuma Asogi]], tells the bailiff that the verdict has let to pass, so calling Naruhodo guilty is wrong even if he was a bailiff. Asogi brings up that the incident has published in the newspaper and asks Naruhodo if he did it. Naruhodo says that he would never commit something like murder. Asogi then tells Naruhodo to keep his chin up and that he has faith in him.
 
   
  +
=="Opening"==
Naruhodo then thinks back to just before the incident had just occurred. He was congratulating Asogi on receiving news that Asogi's overseas studies were confirmed. He wants to go overseas to see in Great British Empire to change the judicial system of Japan. Asogi offers Naruhodo to accompany him on his trip, but Naruhodo is unsure so Asogi offers to ask another time. Naruhodo decides to stay while Asogi leaves.
 
  +
{{Quote||The Empire of Japan - after opening its doors a push for cultural transformation brought great waves of Western influence to this Far Eastern island nation. The revolution washed over the land, making life in the capital exciting and unsettling. It was a period of great change, and some were swept away by the tide. But for one man the turbulence of that era was just the beginning of an extraordinary story.}}
 
[[File:John H Watsons Crime Scene.png|thumb|Wilson's body slumped over in his chair.]]
 
A gunshot rang out in the restaurant La Carneval and the body of a deceased English gentleman was found. As the authorities arrived, a young Japanese man was seen holding a gun in front of the victim.
   
  +
Some time earlier, the man, a student at [[Imperial Yumei University]] named [[Ryunosuke Naruhodo]], was dining with his fellow student and friend, [[Kazuma Asogi]], who was to participate in a student exchange program between Japan and Britain. Asogi aspired to study Britain's judicial system to help him change the judicial system of Japan. Asogi wished that Naruhodo could come with him and "have a wild time tearing up the streets of Her Majesty's City of London together," but sadly it was not that simple. Asogi eventually left while Naruhodo stayed behind. Shortly after that was when the shot was fired.
Naruhodo then snaps back to the present as someone calls for Asogi. The person was Yujin Mikotoba and accompanying him was his daughter, [[Susato Mikotoba]]. Yujin tells Asogi to go see the judge in his chambers, since Asogi sent an application for a change of the defense attorney fairly recently, that it caused some disarray. Susato accompanies Asogi to the Judge's chambers.
 
   
  +
:''8:43 a.m.''
As the two left, Yujin tells Naruhodo that while Asogi's overseas studies are confirmed, if he loses today's trial, the program will be suspended and Asogi will never get another chance. Naruhodo is shocked and asks how this decision came to be. Yujin says that the Japanese Empire selected Asogi from a large amount of candidates to study abroad.
 
  +
[[File:My Beautiful Mophead Husband.png|thumb|left|Naruhodo remembering his meeting with Asogi.]]
  +
Three days after the murder, Naruhodo and Asogi arrived at the [[Supreme Court of Judicature]], where the former was to stand trial and the latter intended on advocating for his defence. [[Yujin Mikotoba]], professor at Yumei University, also arrived with a young woman. Professor Mikotoba informed Asogi that he was being summoned to the [[Seishiro Jigoku|judge]]'s chambers, to which the woman escorted him. Professor Mikotoba then informed Naruhodo that, if Asogi lost this trial, the offer extended to him to study in Britain would be permanently revoked. Furthermore, there were certain peculiarities in the trial that would make it difficult to secure a not guilty verdict. Pressed for time, Professor Mikotoba instructed Naruhodo to answer "I do" to the first question the judge would ask, explaining that Asogi must not be the defence lawyer in the trial.
   
 
=="Trial Start"==
Naruhodo then states that he is not guilty. But Yujin says that with the evidence mounted against him and given the fact that today's trial is unique, it would be very difficult. Naruhodo asks what he can do so Yujin tells to him that after the judge asks a question towards the defense, Naruhodo must say "I am" before anyone else.
 
  +
:''9:00 a.m.''
  +
From the beginning, the first peculiarity was apparent: this was a closed trial, with only military and government officials allowed to attend. The defence's request to have Asogi advocate for Naruhodo had been made last-minute, and in light of this, the judge asked for a confirmation of who would advocate for the defendant. Asogi started to state his confirmation but was interrupted by Naruhodo, who declared that he would be defending himself. Asogi had known that this would happen had Naruhodo known about his situation, and lamented that Professor Mikotoba had divulged that information. Prosecutor [[Taketsuchi Auchi]] scoffed at this development, but Asogi bluffed that Naruhodo was confident that he could speak for his own innocence.
   
  +
The judge had Naruhodo relay some basic facts of the case to ensure that he could conduct himself to the standards befitting the Supreme Court. The victim was John Wilson, a British professor of medicine at Yumei University. Japan had recently signed the Anglo-Japanese Treaty of Friendship and Navigation with Britain, so this case was coming under heavy scrutiny and the Japanese government was looking to wrap up the trial as quickly as possible. According to the [[Post-Mortem Report (The Adventure of the Great Departure)|post-mortem report]], the cause of death was blood loss from a gunshot wound, and a [[Photograph of Victim|photographic print]] of the scene indicated that Wilson had been shot at close range. Satisfied at Naruhodo's conduct, the judge gave the floor to the prosecution.
=== The Trial ===
 
The bailiff then says that the trial is about to begin and they must head towards the courtroom. Yujin say that Asogi should not stand as defense, but Naruhodo is the one that ultimately decides. As the bailiff calls for the defendant, Naruhodo is thinking about the situation. If his is found guilty, Asogi will loses his chance to study abroad. As Naruhodo enter the courtroom, he is joined by Asogi. The trial is conducted under absolute secrecy due to a recent treaty between Japan and the Great British Empire. As the trial starts, the judge asks who is standing for the defendant. Naruhodo realizes that this is the question Yujin was talking about. He notices that if he replies with "I am" he would have to defend himself, but Naruhodo goes thought with it because he doesn't want to ruin Asogi's dream.
 
   
  +
[[File:My Cute Ancestor Son.png|thumb|The mysterious woman.]]
Everyone is shocked that and Asogi asks what is Naruhodo is trying to do. Naruhodo explain that he heard from Yujin about what would happen if Asogi were to lose this trial. The prosecution, [[Taketsuchi Auchi|Taketsuki Auchi]], comments on how the defendant's attorney is abandoning him, but Asogi exclaims that the one who knew of the defendant's innocence was the defendant himself.
 
  +
Auchi's first witness was [[Satoru Hosonaga]], the head waiter at [[La Carneval]], who testified that the incident had occurred a little after 2 in the afternoon. Hosonaga had been putting away utensils in the kitchen when he heard the gunshot. He had then hurried to the dining area to see the victim dead and Naruhodo beside him, gun in hand. Hosonaga then claimed that Wilson had dined alone at his table, and no one else had been around that table. This shocked Naruhodo; while he had approached to greet Wilson after Asogi left, he clearly remembered a woman sitting opposite the late professor.
   
  +
Naruhodo challenged Hosonaga's claim, but the latter insisted that his testimony was correct. In fact, after witnessing the scene, he had hastily drawn a sketch of the seating arrangements in the restaurant, on the back of [[Waiter's Business Card|his business card]]. The judge accepted the card as evidence, though Hosonaga was notably shaken at this. Auchi warned the defence that he had more witnesses to establish the defendant's guilt decisively, causing Naruhodo to lose hope, but Asogi stood firm, encouraging his friend not to quit when the battle had barely even started.
The judge beings to see if Naruhodo is fit to do the job by asking some questions about the incident. The victim's name is [[John H. Watson]]. Since the victim was British, the Japanese government is looking to put the blame on someone. Naruhodo was the prime suspect due to him being at the scene of the crime and was holding a gun.
 
   
  +
[[File:Ryuunosuke With A Gun.png|thumb|left|Naruhodo picking up Wilson's gun.]]
Naruhodo thinks back to just after Asogi left on the day of the incident. Naruhodo noticed the victim at the restaurant and went up to him to say hello.
 
  +
The witnesses warned about were [[Iyesa Nosa]], an Imperial Army sergeant, and [[Kyurio Korekuta]], an antique dealer. They had been dining together, eating steak and discussing a curio that Korekuta had, when the gunshot rang out. Nosa claimed to have seen the precise moment that Naruhodo had fired on Wilson, testifying that the former had shot the latter from behind. Naruhodo explained to Asogi his side of the story: he had gotten up to leave when he noticed an English-made gun near Wilson. Thinking it belonged to the professor, Naruhodo had picked it up, right before the gunshot rang out.
   
  +
Asogi instructed Naruhodo to assert his right to a cross-examination. With some help from Asogi, Naruhodo pointed out a contradiction: the photographic print showed a bullet wound at the front, and the post-mortem report stated that the bullet had not passed through the body. Contrary to Nosa's claim, Wilson had been shot in the chest. At this, Nosa admitted that had been looking at his steak and had not actually seen the moment of crime. Korekuta, too, had not seen the key moment, instead looking under the table for a valuable Hōei era Koban coin that he had lost.
Naruhodo snaps back to the trial and is asked to present what was the caused of death. The autopsy report states that the cause of death was blood loss from the gunshot wound. Auchi also presents a photograph of the body and submits it as evidence.
 
   
  +
The two witnesses nonetheless testified that the victim had dined alone at the time, and Nosa had not seen anyone other than Naruhodo, so he was the only one who could have committed the murder. To corroborate this further, Auchi presented [[Crime Scene Photograph (The Adventure of the Great Departure)|another photographic print]] showing the table with one half-eaten steak lunch. Naruhodo cursed the fact that the incident had occurred later in the afternoon with so few guests as witnesses, though the timing of the lunch did pique the judge's curiosity. Auchi explained that a [[Medical Report Card|medical report card]] had been found in Wilson's jacket pocket, describing an appointment ending at 1 in the afternoon. Naruhodo and Asogi requested that this report card be submitted into evidence, and examined it to discover that the appointment was for a tooth extraction. A note was written on the card strictly forbidding food and drink other than water for three hours after the procedure. This completely changed the meaning of the photographic print of the steak, as it now proved that another individual had been dining at the same table as Wilson.
=== The First Witness ===
 
The first witness is called to the stand. His name is [[Satoru Hosonaga]] and he is a waiter at the restaurant. In his testimony, the victim was spending time at the restaurant a little after 2 pm. After the victim finished eating, three groups of people came. Satoru was cleaning utensils in the kitchen when he heard the gunshot. He then came out of the kitchen to see the victim dead and the defendant with a firearm in his hand. No one else stood close to the victim and the defendant.
 
   
  +
Asogi warned the witnesses that, should it turn out that they had lied in their testimonies, they would be charged with perjury and deemed complicit in the murder. This sent Nosa and Korekuta into a panic, forcing the latter to reveal that someone had ordered them to conceal the presence of a woman in their testimonies. Judging by their reactions, it was someone with great influence, from the government, military, or police. Naruhodo examined Hosonaga's business card and alerted the court to his real job title, and the reason he had been so hesitant to submit the card: "Chief Inspector Satoru Hosonaga, Primary Criminal Investigation Division, Imperial Police Bureau."
Naruhodo then remembers a woman sitting at the same table as the victim on the day of the incident. Naruhodo objects and states it to the court but was dismissed due to him being the accused. The waiter present a card with the seating arrangements at the time with where the victim was marked on it. The card was handed over as evidence.
 
   
  +
Hosonaga explained that he had been investigating undercover at the restaurant due to a string of incidents occurring there, unrelated to the murder. He also admitted that he had seen a British woman sitting with Wilson, but had received special orders from the bureau to release her and erase all evidence that she had been there. It was already bad for an Englishman to be killed on Japanese soil, but to accuse an Englishwoman of the crime without evidence would have been completely out of the question. Asogi recalled that there were a number of British exchange students at Yumei University, and one of them was a woman from the medical faculty's research laboratory. Impressed by Asogi, Hosonaga revealed that he had checked the identity of the woman at the restaurant, and she was the exact woman Asogi described, named [[Jezaille Brett]]. The judge ordered a recess while Hosonaga located Brett and escorted her to the courtroom.
The judge and prosecution offer that if Naruhodo pleads guilty, his sentence will be reduced slightly. Naruhodo asks Asogi if he should pleads guilty. Asogi says that he has faith in him and is he willing to betray his faith.
 
   
  +
=="Recess"==
Asogi then hits the desk with a karate chop and states that the defense is here to prove the defendant's innocence and that the trial should continue.
 
  +
:''11:38 a.m.''
  +
Asogi commended Naruhodo on his performance, adding that he was perhaps suited to be an attorney. Naruhodo was relieved that he was finally being believed, as he prided himself on his powers of observation. Unfortunately for said powers, Hosonaga had immediately apprehended him and taken him to a small pantry beside the kitchen, so he had no idea what had happened in the dining area after that. Professor Mikotoba congratulated the two and admitted that he had wanted the trial not to get in the way of Japan sending its brightest young stars overseas. Asogi, however, stated that he would not bother going anyway if he could not help his friend in his time of need. Regardless, Professor Mikotoba implored Naruhodo to find the truth, as he was the one who had offered Wilson his teaching position at Yumei University. He then sent the woman accompanying him to retrieve "something I think we may need." As the recess ended, Naruhodo thanked Asogi for putting his faith in him.
   
  +
=="Miss Brett's Appearance"==
=== The Next Witnesses ===
 
  +
:''12:09 p.m.''
The next two witnesses are [[Taizou Uzukumaru]] and [[Sanmon Sonohigurashi]]. They were both present at the restaurant when the crime occurred. They were talking about rare treasures. Taizou saw the accused fired the gun killing the victim and then Sanmon got onto the floor.
 
  +
Auchi, against all odds, had received permission from the government to have Brett testify. He voiced his frustration at this latest development, as he was now undergoing scrutiny. Asogi brushed off Auchi's concerns, making him more agitated. As Asogi wondered aloud whether they were in a court controlled by Japan or by England, Auchi lectured him on Japan's precarious position and its need to secure its own future. Naruhodo stepped in and replied that a country that did not uphold the truth in its justice system had no future at all.
   
  +
Jezaille Brett was summoned to the stand. She apparently could only speak English, so Hosonaga stood in as an interpreter. She testified that Naruhodo had gotten into an argument with Wilson and shot him dead with his own gun. She also claimed that she did not carry a gun and there was no place to conceal one in her attire, which she had also worn on the day of the murder. Naruhodo interrogated her on the details of the steak lunch, learning that she had heard about the dentist appointment beforehand. Brett also revealed that the crime scene photograph showed the table exactly as it had been left after the murder. She added that the two diners had each had a glass of carbonated water. Naruhodo pointed out that the photo of the table had only one wine glass, making these two facts seemingly contradictory. Brett explained that she had hidden her wine glass in her handbag due to shock. Believing this to be his chance, Naruhodo supposed that Brett could have also stowed away the real murder weapon in her handbag. Unfortunately for him, however, Hosonaga revealed [[Photograph of Handbag|a photographic print of the handbag]], showing that it was a meshwork bag, the wine glass clearly visible inside, and nothing else.
Naruhodo tells Asogi what happened. After greeting the victim, Naruhodo went back to his table to finish his coffee. When he started to leave, he noticed an English made pistol next to the victim. He thought it was the professor so he stood up to give it to him when he heard the gunshot.
 
   
  +
[[File:Bull.png|thumb|The victim's burn mark.]]
Asogi then tells Naruhodo to request a cross examination quickly. As the prosecution was about to have the trial conclude, Naruhodo requests a cross examination. Auchi was about to deny it when Asogi comes in and says that the defense has a right to perform one.
 
  +
The judge declared the cross-examination over, with the last photograph having no apparent further significance. Even Asogi was at a loss. Naruhodo, however, noticed something that did not seem right. Requesting a chance to inspect the photo, he pointed to a peculiarly shaped burn mark on Wilson's wrist. Brett nervously requested that she be dismissed, but it was too late; Naruhodo pulled out the crime scene photograph and identified a bull insignia on the metal plate that the steak was served on, matching the shape of the burn mark. Hosonaga discerned from looking at the burn injury that it was relatively fresh and severe, and would have had Wilson screaming in pain, but he had heard no such scream at any point in his undercover stint. Naruhodo reached a startling conclusion: Wilson had already died before suffering the burn, and more crucially, before being shot.
   
  +
At this point, Brett began to show her true nature, speaking Japanese and revealing that she could do it all along. She also showed a more openly racist side, calling Japanese a "vulgar tone" and claiming that Japan's "inferior" investigative techniques would not be able to detect any other cause of death even if Wilson had died before the gunshot. When asked to elaborate on the latter remark, she explained that, in Britain, the police would try to preserve the crime scene and store evidence for later examination. This seemed to agitate Hosonaga, who explained that he had done what Brett was talking about, and had taken [[Carbonated Water Bottle|the bottle of carbonated water]] served to Wilson and Brett for the sake of preserving it as evidence. Naruhodo suggested that Brett had poisoned the water, but Hosonaga had already ordered tests for every poison available in Japan, and found no trace of any of them. Once again, both Naruhodo and Kazuma were at a loss, but just then, Professor Mikotoba's assistant arrived with a small package and introduced herself as "[[Susato Mikotoba]], judicial assistant to the defence."
As the cross examination begins, Naruhodo notices a contradiction. He tries to point it out by presenting the photo of the crime scene, but gets tongue tied. Asogi then hits the desk and tells the court that the in the photo the victim was shot in the chest. Taizou said he was shot in the back so it was a contradiction. Taizou then explains that he was actually looking the beefsteak so he didn't witness the crime when the gun was shot. Sanmon, at the time, was looking for a valuable coin he lost. Due to those statements, Asogi states that the testimony is inconclusive.
 
   
  +
=="Susato's Sudden Entrance"==
They continue with the trial and it is revealed that Taizou brought along his son, [[Kuroumaru Uzukumaru|Kuroumaru]]. The two witnesses claim that it doesn't change anything because there was no one else. Naruhodo exclaims that there was someone else there, but Auchi presents a photo that shows that the table was set for one.
 
  +
:''1:14 p.m.''
  +
Though women were not permitted into the courtroom other than to testify, Susato was granted enough time to present the defence with a new piece of evidence: [[Jezaille's Report|a research paper by Brett]] on a substance called [[curare]]. The defence described to the court what curare was, based on the paper: a deadly poison, unknown to Japanese law enforcement, used by South American indigenous tribes to lace their arrows for hunting animals for food. This toxin would cause instant paralysis, eventually causing the muscles that control breathing to fail, resulting in death by suffocation, all without any outward signs that anything was wrong. In response to this, Brett took a drink from the bottle, demonstrating no ill effects. Naruhodo pointed out that the report only mentioned the poison working if it entered the body through an open wound; as its use in South America readily demonstrated, consuming it without having it enter a wound was completely safe. Brett countered that the same should have applied to Wilson, but, as conviction boiled within Naruhodo, he cried out, "[[Objection!]]" and stated that Wilson had undergone a tooth extraction, a fact that Brett had known about in advance, which she had used to her advantage to carry out the murder. Just as victory seemed within Naruhodo's grasp, Brett snatched the bottle and "accidentally" dropped it, shattering it to pieces while the carpet underneath soaked up the water.
   
  +
[[File:This Steak Is Suteki In Color.png|thumb|The bloodstain on the plate.]]
Naruhodo was about to give up when Asogi tells Naruhodo to keep his head high. Auchi presents a medical report found in the breast pocket of the victim. The report states that the victim just came from a dentist appointment and was give instructions of not eating any food for the next three hours. This is a contradiction, proving that there someone there with the victim.
 
  +
With the evidence to prove their poison theory gone, the argument returned to the matter of who had shot Wilson. Naruhodo went back through his memories and recalled seeing a bloodstain on the plate of steak. This bloodstain would prove that Wilson's killer had taken the shot from the opposite side of the table. It turned out that Hosonaga had taken the plates of steak from both Brett and Nosa after the incident. Hosonaga then retrieved [[Plate of Steak|the plate that he had taken from Wilson's table]], but no blood was found on it, much to Naruhodo's surprise.
   
  +
[[File:Taizou broken down.png|left|thumb|Iyesa Nosa, the La Carneval thief.]]
As the defense continue to press, Sanmon let slip that they were ordered to testify that there was no lady at the scene. It appears that someone scared them into silence. Naruhodo believe it was the waiter and the card that the waiter presented says that Satoru is actually a detective.
 
  +
Desperate for another clue, Naruhodo lifted up the steak and underneath found a rare Hōei era Koban coin. Nosa and Korekuta were brought back, and the latter confirmed that it was the same coin that he had lost. Hosonaga explained that he had been investigating a series of thefts at the restaurant. With a similar theft having happened at the time of the murder, the thief could only have been Nosa. [[Breakdown|Broken]], Nosa admitted to the thefts; due to his low pay as a low-ranking soldier, he only wanted to provide for his infant son [[Aido Nosa|Aido]]. Every three days, he would go to the restaurant and search for his next mark, all while enjoying a steak meal, apparently chomping into it without using a knife and fork. He had initially slipped the coin into his pocket, but after the shooting, he had "slipped it under the steak" instead, in case he got searched.
   
  +
Brett, once again confident that Naruhodo had exhausted all of his options, requested permission to leave, commenting incredulously on the idea of biting into a steak instead of using a knife and fork. That off-handed comment, however, gave Naruhodo one last idea: the steak from Wilson's table had bite marks, which meant that it belonged to somebody who had taken bites out of the steak directly, namely Nosa and not Brett. Nosa admitted that the plate with the coin belonged to him. Once Hosonaga had revealed that he was an undercover police officer, Nosa had decided to switch his plate with Brett's, seeing his opportunity when Naruhodo was arrested and sent to the kitchen. Hosonaga presented the other plate, and the bloodstain could clearly be seen. It served as decisive evidence of Naruhodo's assertion that the perpetrator had shot from across the table. Brett, shocked at being outdone "by a Japanese schoolboy", [[Breakdown|screamed as the swan on her hat came alive and dragged her around before ascending to "heaven"]].
As they were about to confirm if Satoru ordered them to keep silent, Satoru appeared. Satoru explains that he was working undercover at the restaurant due to a string of incidents that occurred at the restaurant. Satoru avoided sat that the woman was there due to orders at the police headquarters saying to release the British woman there. The reason why was because they wanted to keep a good relationship with the Great British Empire. Asogi remembers that there was an exchange student from Great Britain and the student was a female and was under the victim's research facility in the medical block. Satoru confirms this and the judge sends Satoru to get the exchange student [[Jezail Brett]].
 
   
  +
Finally, Brett confessed to the crime, explaining that she had intended to leave immediately after seeing Wilson sip the poisoned drink, so that she could make it look as if he had dined alone. However, with Naruhodo showing up and seeing her, she had to change her plans. She had made sure that Wilson was sitting when sipping the water, then put his pistol on the floor for Naruhodo to pick up. She had then used her own pistol, hidden from under her skirt, to shoot the corpse. As Hosonaga was detaining Naruhodo in the kitchen, Brett had rotated Wilson's chair, failing to notice Nosa switching the plates of steak. After requesting to speak with the judge in private later, she was arrested and taken away.
=== The Phantom Woman ===
 
A break was taken. Asogi comments on how Naruhodo can still find contradictions will being very nervous. Asogi suggests maybe Naruhodo is suited to be an attorney. Naruhodo brushes it of, claiming he doesn't want now frightful thoughts.
 
   
  +
Auchi swore vengeance against Naruhodo for this loss. Asogi responded that Auchi had become conceited with age, but the old would have to stand aside for the sake of the new. [[Breakdown|He sliced off Auchi's hair with his katana, promising that, even after a thousand years, Auchi's clan would never rival Naruhodo's.]]
Asogi asks if Naruhodo noticed anything about the lady, but Naruhodo says no. Yujin then comes up to congratulate the two on how well they work together. Asogi then talks to Yujin on how he thinks that this was a set up. Yujin didn't want Asogi's studies to be suspended so he intervened. Asogi feels pathetic because he can't save his best friend so he resigns from the trip if Naruhodo is found guilty. Then Yujin reveals that he offer the position of professor to the victim was him. Yujin tells the two that since the person is part of the Great British Empire, it would be very difficult. As the break was about to end, Naruhodo says thank you to Asogi for putting faith in him. Asogi says he did it as a man, attorney, and friend.
 
   
  +
The judge gave his closing remarks. He congratulated Naruhodo on his excellent use of evidence and deduction, and was hopeful for how the scientific ideas of the West would shape the future of law in Japan. He also told Asogi to learn all that he could in Britain, and fulfill his "mission". He again addressed Naruhodo, sensing "unusual potential" in him before delivering his verdict of "not guilty".
As the trial starts up again, Auchi comments on how might their ties with Great Britain could of had worsen by this trial. Asogi and Naruhodo comments on how justice is put behind in favor of politics and good ties.
 
   
  +
=="Conclusion"==
The trial commences and Jezail Brett arrives, but she can only speak English so Satoru is acting as a translator. She was there at the scene of the crime and was having a late lunch with the victim. She ordered a beefsteak for herself. Then Naruhodo came over and it evolved into a dispute. He pulled out a gun and shot the victim.
 
  +
:''2:46 p.m.''
  +
Naruhodo, Asogi, and the Mikotobas celebrated the verdict in the defendants' antechamber. Professor Mikotoba told them that he had met Wilson in Britain, and they had worked at the same hospital. Asogi swore to him on his katana that he would learn all that he could on his own journey. As for Brett, Hosonaga revealed that the British foreign affairs ministry had demanded that she be sent to Shanghai, [[China]], to be tried under a British consular court. Asogi was confused; the treaty should have rendered those courts void. Nevertheless, they could only hope that Brett would be brought to justice one day. As Hosonaga invited them all to La Carneval, Naruhodo accepted that he may never know why Brett had killed Wilson.
   
  +
As everyone else left, Naruhodo commended Asogi for his skills, but the latter replied that the former had a natural talent for being a defence lawyer. To him, a lawyer's most crucial weapon was not any sort of skill or knowledge of the law, but their ability to make a choice about what to believe in, and holding strong in that belief against all odds, much like Naruhodo's trust in him. Asogi then wanted to ask Naruhodo for a favour, but was interrupted by Hosonaga, who informed them that he had arranged some rickshaws for them all to ride to La Carneval. The favour would have to wait, but little did Naruhodo know that it would change his life.
Naruhodo exclaims he did do it. Asogi says that he hasn't learn anything. Jezail is wearing the same clothes as the one she wore at the day of the incident and there is no way for her to conceal a hand gun.
 
   
  +
==References to other cases==
The defense cross exam Jezail. They find out that the victim had carbonated water. Naruhodo point out that in the photo depicting the table has only one wine glass. Auchi believes that the missing wine glass is trivial, but Asogi exclaims that if the police disposed the wine glass to cover the woman's tracks. Satoru then says he did nothing of the short. Jezail explains she took the second wine glass away because she was in shock and hide it in her small handbag.
 
  +
* The clinic that Wilson visited for his tooth extraction is called "Hotta Clinic", which is the Japanese name of the [[Hotti Clinic]] from ''[[Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Justice for All]]'' and ''[[Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Trials and Tribulations]]''.
  +
* Asogi's comment that [[Payne (family)|Auchi's clan]] would never rival [[Wright (family)|Naruhodo's]] does indeed come to pass, as neither [[Winston Payne|Winston]] nor [[Gaspen Payne]] have been able to win in court in any of their in-game appearances in a trial where [[Phoenix Wright]] is present. Additionally, Auchi's hair after Asogi cut it resembles Winston's hair in ''[[Turnabout Trump]]''.
  +
* At one point when presenting a profile incorrectly during the trial, Naruhodo comments that Auchi makes him "wince in pain", a direct reference to Winston Payne's name.
   
 
==Notes==
Naruhodo then realizes that a handgun could of had been hidden in the handbag. Asogi then says that there must be a second gun at the time of the incident. Naruhodo asks the detective if he inspected the handbag. He did not so, but took a picture of Jezail's handbag. It has an open side and the only thing visible was the wine glass. It was handed over as evidence.
 
  +
*When Jezaille Brett is introduced, the judge exclaims that "no discussions take place without tea" and "it's always ladies first" in England. It is much later revealed in ''[[Twisted Karma and His Last Bow]]'' and ''[[The Resolve of Ryunosuke Naruhodo]]'' that not only was he one of the three exchange students who travelled to Britain ten years ago, but he also had experienced a trial in a British courtroom. In this context, this pair of exclamations does not make much sense for him to make seriously, and is primarily meant as a gag to illustrate how overly polite that he and Auchi are trying to be to Brett.
  +
*The Anglo-Japanese Treaty of Friendship and Navigation [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=auNt53YWo8I seems to be based] on the [[Wikipedia:Anglo-Japanese Friendship Treaty|1854 Anglo-Japanese Friendship Treaty]] and the [[Wikipedia:Anglo-Japanese Treaty of Commerce and Navigation|1894 Anglo-Japanese Treaty of Commerce and Navigation]]. The latter is of particular importance as it entails the end of extraterritoriality for British subjects (hence Jezaille Brett being expected to be tried on Japanese soil after Naruhodo's trial) and the end of consular courts (hence the surprise that Brett would be tried in one).
   
  +
===Typos===
The judge was about to hand down his verdict when Naruhodo interrupts, saying that they need to inspect the photo. They inspect the photo to find that the victim has a scar on his hand. It was left out due it being deemed not the cause of death. Naruhodo points out that the burn mark is an exact replica of the insigne on the iron plate that the beefsteak was on. Auchi tries to dismiss it, but Asogi exclaims that a burn would of had not slip by the restaurant due to public concern. Also, Satoru states that a burn like that would of had caused intense pain, but has not heard any loud scream. Naruhodo agrees that he heard no screams so that must mean he got it after he was dead.
 
  +
*In Jezaille Brett's testimony "The Victim's 'Death'," she says, "If there's some other way a man's life can '''been''' taken without leaving a trace, please, do show me."
 
  +
* When accusing Brett of poisoning Dr. Wilson, Ryunosuke says, "There's only person who could possibly have done it!" which should be "There's only '''one''' person who could possibly have done it!"
Jezail agrees to talk to preserve the relationship between Japan and Britain and she said it in Japanese. The reason why she wanted a translator was because she thought that Japanese was unfit for a lady of her station to speak. She didn't know about the burn mark and was shocked that a gunshot stole the life of the victim. She also believes that the police can't produce any new evidence. She wants to increase the defendant's punishment, but Asogi says that Naruhodo is exceptional.
 
  +
* During Brett's confession, she admits that she hid a pistol under her skirt, to which Auchi responds, "U-Under '''you''' skirt...?"
 
  +
{{Episodes}}
As the two press the witness, they notice that Satoru is reacting strangely to Jezail's testimony. They question Satoru and find out that since the police force is still developing, Satoru may have took some stuff from the crime scene. He presents the bottle with carbonated water and gives it as evidence. Naruhodo believes that in order to not leave a trace, the victim has to be poisoned. Satoru then states that the police investigated the bottle and found no poison. Naruhodo is about to give up when Susato shows up. She was about to be thrown out when she gives Asogi and Naruhodo Jezail's research notes. They request to look at the notes and research lab because they found out that Jezail was researching a poison that has no current methods to detect it. The victim would not scream or wither in pain because the poison would paralyze the victim's muscles. Not only that, but the muscles that control breathing would stop so it was death by suffocation.
 
  +
{{DEFAULTSORT:Adventure of the Great Departure, The}}
 
  +
[[Category:Cases]]
Jezail takes a drink from the bottle and is fine. But Naruhodo points out that in the research paper, the poison has to enter a wound to be deadly. Jezail then points out that the professor could of had drank it and would of had been fine. Naruhodo thinks it over and states that since the victim had his tooth extracted then the poison could of had entered through that wound. Jezail then takes the bottle and drops it. They can't pick up the water because the floor is carpeted.
 
  +
[[Category:Game episodes]]
 
  +
[[Category:Trials]]
[[File:Taizou_broken_down.png|200px|thumb|Taizou Uzukumaru, the Las Quintos thief with the very first breakdown.]]
 
  +
[[Category:The Great Ace Attorney: Adventures]]
Naruhodo then remembers a clue. That there was blood on the plate of the beefsteak. He asks Satoru if he has the plate. Jezail tries to pin it on Naruhodo, but he points out that the plate is completely behind the victim so the shot came from the back. Satoru brings the meal tray and it has no blood. The defense inspect it and find that this plate has the missing koban coin underneath it. Satoru then explain the incidents that occurred at the restaurant was of thief from foreigners by using the food so Satoru had to go undercover to see who was the perpetrator. It turns out to be Taizou because he gets little pay and needs to provide for his son.
 
 
Jezail commits on the soldier's eating habits and actions as barbaric and Naruhodo points out that the beefsteak have bite marks so it must have been put there. Naruhodo then says the beefsteak that was presented belongs to Taizou so he must of had switched the plates. Naruhodo demands that the other beefsteak be presented. Jezail tries to say that it is irrelevant, but Asogi pushed it because of Naruhodo's memories. Satoru presents the steak and there is blood on it so that means the victim's back was towards him. So the only one who could have done it was Jezail. Jezail Brett [[Breakdown|went crazy with birds and went to heaven]]. She confesses and states that she was about to leave when Naruhodo shows up and in order to keep the body from falling order, she used the chair. She then thought of a plan. She has two handguns hidden under her skirt so she dropped one and used the second to shoot the victim's body. As Satoru detains Naruhodo, she rotated the chair.
 
 
As the trial concludes, Auchi swears vengeance against Naruhodo. Asogi says that prideful will be uprooted by the next generation and uses his sword to cut Auchi's hair, making it come undone. Asogi then states that even in a thousand years, Auchi's family will never be an adversary towards Naruhodo's.
 
 
== After the Trial ==
 
Yujin and his daughter congratulate the two on their victory. Yujin explains that he came to knew Professor Watson when he was studying forensic science in Great Britain and worked with him in a hospital. Yujin then states that Jezail will not be tried here. Satoru then comes in an explains that the Japanese Courts can't judge a foreigner's crime due to a treaty. The British government is following so they can trial Jezail for her crimes.
 
 
As they go to celebrate, Naruhodo thanks Asogi for his help. Asogi the replies that he only helped in the beginning and that Naruhodo has a talent for being an attorney. Naruhodo then exclaims he doesn't want to go through another situation like that ever again. Asogi then tells Naruhodo that an attorney's greatest power is believing. Believing in your client and in yourself. They then go to celebrate. As the episode end, Naruhodo reflects on how something changed his life.
 
 
== Trivia ==
 
* This trial eventually has the defendant defend himself like how [[Phoenix Wright|Phoenix]] defended himself in [[Turnabout Sisters]].
 
* The trial includes interviewing multiple witnesses at a time, like in [[Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney|Professor Layton vs Phoenix Wright]].
 
* Asogi comments on how Auchi's descendants will never be an advisory against Naruhodo's which comes true as the Paynes never won a case against the Wright Anything Agency
 
* Instead of confetti after the trial, there are cherry blossoms.
 
 
{{episodes}}
 
{{stub}}
 
[[Category:Cases|!Adventure of the Great Departure, The]]
 
[[Category:Dai Gyakuten Saiban: Naruhodō Ryūnosuke no Bōken|!Adventure of the Great Departure, The]]
 

Latest revision as of 07:47, 17 April 2024

The Adventure of the Great Departure
Transcript
This article contains information about Ace Attorney media that has been
recently released and thus likely contains spoilers!
Steel Samurai
The information in this article comes from a game, demo, or other media that has been recently released worldwide. This article may need input from an editor who has personal experience with the media in question. If you have, you can help the Ace Attorney Wiki by expanding this article. Please heed the manual of style when adding information.

Readers of this page should be aware that this article likely contains MAJOR SPOILERS concerning the media in question.

You have been warned!

Ryunosuke Naruhodo
I won't deny that I'm no expert. I'm just a student. And one who could arguably study harder, too. But standing here now in our Supreme Court, there is one thing that I feel very strongly: A country that fails to uphold the truth in its justice system is a country with no future at all.

Episode 1: The Adventure of the Great Departure is the first episode of the game The Great Ace Attorney: Adventures. In late 19th century Japan, during a turbulent time of increasing Western influence on Japanese culture, the stage is set for an international incident. John Wilson, a visiting professor from the United Kingdom, is shot in the restaurant La Carneval, and Ryunosuke Naruhodo, a Japanese university student, is caught red-handed holding a gun. With the Anglo-Japanese Treaty of Friendship and Navigation having just been signed, the Japanese government sees this murder of a British citizen on their soil as a threat to continued good relations between the two island nations. As such, Naruhodo is sent to the Supreme Court of Judicature to stand in a closed trial, surrounded by military and government officials. Standing by his side is his best friend, Kazuma Asogi, who intends to represent him as his lawyer, but plans change when Naruhodo is informed of the risk that Asogi is taking by taking this case.

This episode serves as an introduction not only to the general mechanics and conventions of the Ace Attorney series, but also to aspects specific to the setting of The Great Ace Attorney Chronicles. For example, Wilson's gun is never mentioned to have been examined and the player is unable to do so themselves due to the firearm not appearing in the court record; this is due to technology in the game's setting being insufficient to perform a ballistics test. In a modern setting like in other Ace Attorney games, such a test would have immediately proven that the gun held by Naruhodo was not the one used to shoot Wilson. Additionally, it is the longest introductory episode in the series, consisting of three trial segments.

Acts and chapters[]

Act Chapter
"Trial, Part 1" "Opening"
"Trial Start"
"Trial, Part 2" "Recess"
"Miss Brett's Appearance"
"Trial, Part 3" "Susato's Sudden Entrance"
"Conclusion"

Timeline[]

To edit the information in this table, go to Template:Timeline and edit the information there.
Date Event type / related incident Description Notes
November 19, GAA-1 (Meiji 34) The Adventure of the Great Departure John Wilson is murdered. N/A
November 22, GAA-1 (Meiji 34) The Adventure of the Great Departure Closed trial of Ryunosuke Naruhodo for the murder of John Wilson. He represents himself, thus marking his début as a lawyer. N/A

"Opening"[]

The Empire of Japan - after opening its doors a push for cultural transformation brought great waves of Western influence to this Far Eastern island nation. The revolution washed over the land, making life in the capital exciting and unsettling. It was a period of great change, and some were swept away by the tide. But for one man the turbulence of that era was just the beginning of an extraordinary story.
John H Watsons Crime Scene

Wilson's body slumped over in his chair.

A gunshot rang out in the restaurant La Carneval and the body of a deceased English gentleman was found. As the authorities arrived, a young Japanese man was seen holding a gun in front of the victim.

Some time earlier, the man, a student at Imperial Yumei University named Ryunosuke Naruhodo, was dining with his fellow student and friend, Kazuma Asogi, who was to participate in a student exchange program between Japan and Britain. Asogi aspired to study Britain's judicial system to help him change the judicial system of Japan. Asogi wished that Naruhodo could come with him and "have a wild time tearing up the streets of Her Majesty's City of London together," but sadly it was not that simple. Asogi eventually left while Naruhodo stayed behind. Shortly after that was when the shot was fired.

8:43 a.m.
My Beautiful Mophead Husband

Naruhodo remembering his meeting with Asogi.

Three days after the murder, Naruhodo and Asogi arrived at the Supreme Court of Judicature, where the former was to stand trial and the latter intended on advocating for his defence. Yujin Mikotoba, professor at Yumei University, also arrived with a young woman. Professor Mikotoba informed Asogi that he was being summoned to the judge's chambers, to which the woman escorted him. Professor Mikotoba then informed Naruhodo that, if Asogi lost this trial, the offer extended to him to study in Britain would be permanently revoked. Furthermore, there were certain peculiarities in the trial that would make it difficult to secure a not guilty verdict. Pressed for time, Professor Mikotoba instructed Naruhodo to answer "I do" to the first question the judge would ask, explaining that Asogi must not be the defence lawyer in the trial.

"Trial Start"[]

9:00 a.m.

From the beginning, the first peculiarity was apparent: this was a closed trial, with only military and government officials allowed to attend. The defence's request to have Asogi advocate for Naruhodo had been made last-minute, and in light of this, the judge asked for a confirmation of who would advocate for the defendant. Asogi started to state his confirmation but was interrupted by Naruhodo, who declared that he would be defending himself. Asogi had known that this would happen had Naruhodo known about his situation, and lamented that Professor Mikotoba had divulged that information. Prosecutor Taketsuchi Auchi scoffed at this development, but Asogi bluffed that Naruhodo was confident that he could speak for his own innocence.

The judge had Naruhodo relay some basic facts of the case to ensure that he could conduct himself to the standards befitting the Supreme Court. The victim was John Wilson, a British professor of medicine at Yumei University. Japan had recently signed the Anglo-Japanese Treaty of Friendship and Navigation with Britain, so this case was coming under heavy scrutiny and the Japanese government was looking to wrap up the trial as quickly as possible. According to the post-mortem report, the cause of death was blood loss from a gunshot wound, and a photographic print of the scene indicated that Wilson had been shot at close range. Satisfied at Naruhodo's conduct, the judge gave the floor to the prosecution.

My Cute Ancestor Son

The mysterious woman.

Auchi's first witness was Satoru Hosonaga, the head waiter at La Carneval, who testified that the incident had occurred a little after 2 in the afternoon. Hosonaga had been putting away utensils in the kitchen when he heard the gunshot. He had then hurried to the dining area to see the victim dead and Naruhodo beside him, gun in hand. Hosonaga then claimed that Wilson had dined alone at his table, and no one else had been around that table. This shocked Naruhodo; while he had approached to greet Wilson after Asogi left, he clearly remembered a woman sitting opposite the late professor.

Naruhodo challenged Hosonaga's claim, but the latter insisted that his testimony was correct. In fact, after witnessing the scene, he had hastily drawn a sketch of the seating arrangements in the restaurant, on the back of his business card. The judge accepted the card as evidence, though Hosonaga was notably shaken at this. Auchi warned the defence that he had more witnesses to establish the defendant's guilt decisively, causing Naruhodo to lose hope, but Asogi stood firm, encouraging his friend not to quit when the battle had barely even started.

Ryuunosuke With A Gun

Naruhodo picking up Wilson's gun.

The witnesses warned about were Iyesa Nosa, an Imperial Army sergeant, and Kyurio Korekuta, an antique dealer. They had been dining together, eating steak and discussing a curio that Korekuta had, when the gunshot rang out. Nosa claimed to have seen the precise moment that Naruhodo had fired on Wilson, testifying that the former had shot the latter from behind. Naruhodo explained to Asogi his side of the story: he had gotten up to leave when he noticed an English-made gun near Wilson. Thinking it belonged to the professor, Naruhodo had picked it up, right before the gunshot rang out.

Asogi instructed Naruhodo to assert his right to a cross-examination. With some help from Asogi, Naruhodo pointed out a contradiction: the photographic print showed a bullet wound at the front, and the post-mortem report stated that the bullet had not passed through the body. Contrary to Nosa's claim, Wilson had been shot in the chest. At this, Nosa admitted that had been looking at his steak and had not actually seen the moment of crime. Korekuta, too, had not seen the key moment, instead looking under the table for a valuable Hōei era Koban coin that he had lost.

The two witnesses nonetheless testified that the victim had dined alone at the time, and Nosa had not seen anyone other than Naruhodo, so he was the only one who could have committed the murder. To corroborate this further, Auchi presented another photographic print showing the table with one half-eaten steak lunch. Naruhodo cursed the fact that the incident had occurred later in the afternoon with so few guests as witnesses, though the timing of the lunch did pique the judge's curiosity. Auchi explained that a medical report card had been found in Wilson's jacket pocket, describing an appointment ending at 1 in the afternoon. Naruhodo and Asogi requested that this report card be submitted into evidence, and examined it to discover that the appointment was for a tooth extraction. A note was written on the card strictly forbidding food and drink other than water for three hours after the procedure. This completely changed the meaning of the photographic print of the steak, as it now proved that another individual had been dining at the same table as Wilson.

Asogi warned the witnesses that, should it turn out that they had lied in their testimonies, they would be charged with perjury and deemed complicit in the murder. This sent Nosa and Korekuta into a panic, forcing the latter to reveal that someone had ordered them to conceal the presence of a woman in their testimonies. Judging by their reactions, it was someone with great influence, from the government, military, or police. Naruhodo examined Hosonaga's business card and alerted the court to his real job title, and the reason he had been so hesitant to submit the card: "Chief Inspector Satoru Hosonaga, Primary Criminal Investigation Division, Imperial Police Bureau."

Hosonaga explained that he had been investigating undercover at the restaurant due to a string of incidents occurring there, unrelated to the murder. He also admitted that he had seen a British woman sitting with Wilson, but had received special orders from the bureau to release her and erase all evidence that she had been there. It was already bad for an Englishman to be killed on Japanese soil, but to accuse an Englishwoman of the crime without evidence would have been completely out of the question. Asogi recalled that there were a number of British exchange students at Yumei University, and one of them was a woman from the medical faculty's research laboratory. Impressed by Asogi, Hosonaga revealed that he had checked the identity of the woman at the restaurant, and she was the exact woman Asogi described, named Jezaille Brett. The judge ordered a recess while Hosonaga located Brett and escorted her to the courtroom.

"Recess"[]

11:38 a.m.

Asogi commended Naruhodo on his performance, adding that he was perhaps suited to be an attorney. Naruhodo was relieved that he was finally being believed, as he prided himself on his powers of observation. Unfortunately for said powers, Hosonaga had immediately apprehended him and taken him to a small pantry beside the kitchen, so he had no idea what had happened in the dining area after that. Professor Mikotoba congratulated the two and admitted that he had wanted the trial not to get in the way of Japan sending its brightest young stars overseas. Asogi, however, stated that he would not bother going anyway if he could not help his friend in his time of need. Regardless, Professor Mikotoba implored Naruhodo to find the truth, as he was the one who had offered Wilson his teaching position at Yumei University. He then sent the woman accompanying him to retrieve "something I think we may need." As the recess ended, Naruhodo thanked Asogi for putting his faith in him.

"Miss Brett's Appearance"[]

12:09 p.m.

Auchi, against all odds, had received permission from the government to have Brett testify. He voiced his frustration at this latest development, as he was now undergoing scrutiny. Asogi brushed off Auchi's concerns, making him more agitated. As Asogi wondered aloud whether they were in a court controlled by Japan or by England, Auchi lectured him on Japan's precarious position and its need to secure its own future. Naruhodo stepped in and replied that a country that did not uphold the truth in its justice system had no future at all.

Jezaille Brett was summoned to the stand. She apparently could only speak English, so Hosonaga stood in as an interpreter. She testified that Naruhodo had gotten into an argument with Wilson and shot him dead with his own gun. She also claimed that she did not carry a gun and there was no place to conceal one in her attire, which she had also worn on the day of the murder. Naruhodo interrogated her on the details of the steak lunch, learning that she had heard about the dentist appointment beforehand. Brett also revealed that the crime scene photograph showed the table exactly as it had been left after the murder. She added that the two diners had each had a glass of carbonated water. Naruhodo pointed out that the photo of the table had only one wine glass, making these two facts seemingly contradictory. Brett explained that she had hidden her wine glass in her handbag due to shock. Believing this to be his chance, Naruhodo supposed that Brett could have also stowed away the real murder weapon in her handbag. Unfortunately for him, however, Hosonaga revealed a photographic print of the handbag, showing that it was a meshwork bag, the wine glass clearly visible inside, and nothing else.

Bull

The victim's burn mark.

The judge declared the cross-examination over, with the last photograph having no apparent further significance. Even Asogi was at a loss. Naruhodo, however, noticed something that did not seem right. Requesting a chance to inspect the photo, he pointed to a peculiarly shaped burn mark on Wilson's wrist. Brett nervously requested that she be dismissed, but it was too late; Naruhodo pulled out the crime scene photograph and identified a bull insignia on the metal plate that the steak was served on, matching the shape of the burn mark. Hosonaga discerned from looking at the burn injury that it was relatively fresh and severe, and would have had Wilson screaming in pain, but he had heard no such scream at any point in his undercover stint. Naruhodo reached a startling conclusion: Wilson had already died before suffering the burn, and more crucially, before being shot.

At this point, Brett began to show her true nature, speaking Japanese and revealing that she could do it all along. She also showed a more openly racist side, calling Japanese a "vulgar tone" and claiming that Japan's "inferior" investigative techniques would not be able to detect any other cause of death even if Wilson had died before the gunshot. When asked to elaborate on the latter remark, she explained that, in Britain, the police would try to preserve the crime scene and store evidence for later examination. This seemed to agitate Hosonaga, who explained that he had done what Brett was talking about, and had taken the bottle of carbonated water served to Wilson and Brett for the sake of preserving it as evidence. Naruhodo suggested that Brett had poisoned the water, but Hosonaga had already ordered tests for every poison available in Japan, and found no trace of any of them. Once again, both Naruhodo and Kazuma were at a loss, but just then, Professor Mikotoba's assistant arrived with a small package and introduced herself as "Susato Mikotoba, judicial assistant to the defence."

"Susato's Sudden Entrance"[]

1:14 p.m.

Though women were not permitted into the courtroom other than to testify, Susato was granted enough time to present the defence with a new piece of evidence: a research paper by Brett on a substance called curare. The defence described to the court what curare was, based on the paper: a deadly poison, unknown to Japanese law enforcement, used by South American indigenous tribes to lace their arrows for hunting animals for food. This toxin would cause instant paralysis, eventually causing the muscles that control breathing to fail, resulting in death by suffocation, all without any outward signs that anything was wrong. In response to this, Brett took a drink from the bottle, demonstrating no ill effects. Naruhodo pointed out that the report only mentioned the poison working if it entered the body through an open wound; as its use in South America readily demonstrated, consuming it without having it enter a wound was completely safe. Brett countered that the same should have applied to Wilson, but, as conviction boiled within Naruhodo, he cried out, "Objection!" and stated that Wilson had undergone a tooth extraction, a fact that Brett had known about in advance, which she had used to her advantage to carry out the murder. Just as victory seemed within Naruhodo's grasp, Brett snatched the bottle and "accidentally" dropped it, shattering it to pieces while the carpet underneath soaked up the water.

This Steak Is Suteki In Color

The bloodstain on the plate.

With the evidence to prove their poison theory gone, the argument returned to the matter of who had shot Wilson. Naruhodo went back through his memories and recalled seeing a bloodstain on the plate of steak. This bloodstain would prove that Wilson's killer had taken the shot from the opposite side of the table. It turned out that Hosonaga had taken the plates of steak from both Brett and Nosa after the incident. Hosonaga then retrieved the plate that he had taken from Wilson's table, but no blood was found on it, much to Naruhodo's surprise.

Taizou broken down

Iyesa Nosa, the La Carneval thief.

Desperate for another clue, Naruhodo lifted up the steak and underneath found a rare Hōei era Koban coin. Nosa and Korekuta were brought back, and the latter confirmed that it was the same coin that he had lost. Hosonaga explained that he had been investigating a series of thefts at the restaurant. With a similar theft having happened at the time of the murder, the thief could only have been Nosa. Broken, Nosa admitted to the thefts; due to his low pay as a low-ranking soldier, he only wanted to provide for his infant son Aido. Every three days, he would go to the restaurant and search for his next mark, all while enjoying a steak meal, apparently chomping into it without using a knife and fork. He had initially slipped the coin into his pocket, but after the shooting, he had "slipped it under the steak" instead, in case he got searched.

Brett, once again confident that Naruhodo had exhausted all of his options, requested permission to leave, commenting incredulously on the idea of biting into a steak instead of using a knife and fork. That off-handed comment, however, gave Naruhodo one last idea: the steak from Wilson's table had bite marks, which meant that it belonged to somebody who had taken bites out of the steak directly, namely Nosa and not Brett. Nosa admitted that the plate with the coin belonged to him. Once Hosonaga had revealed that he was an undercover police officer, Nosa had decided to switch his plate with Brett's, seeing his opportunity when Naruhodo was arrested and sent to the kitchen. Hosonaga presented the other plate, and the bloodstain could clearly be seen. It served as decisive evidence of Naruhodo's assertion that the perpetrator had shot from across the table. Brett, shocked at being outdone "by a Japanese schoolboy", screamed as the swan on her hat came alive and dragged her around before ascending to "heaven".

Finally, Brett confessed to the crime, explaining that she had intended to leave immediately after seeing Wilson sip the poisoned drink, so that she could make it look as if he had dined alone. However, with Naruhodo showing up and seeing her, she had to change her plans. She had made sure that Wilson was sitting when sipping the water, then put his pistol on the floor for Naruhodo to pick up. She had then used her own pistol, hidden from under her skirt, to shoot the corpse. As Hosonaga was detaining Naruhodo in the kitchen, Brett had rotated Wilson's chair, failing to notice Nosa switching the plates of steak. After requesting to speak with the judge in private later, she was arrested and taken away.

Auchi swore vengeance against Naruhodo for this loss. Asogi responded that Auchi had become conceited with age, but the old would have to stand aside for the sake of the new. He sliced off Auchi's hair with his katana, promising that, even after a thousand years, Auchi's clan would never rival Naruhodo's.

The judge gave his closing remarks. He congratulated Naruhodo on his excellent use of evidence and deduction, and was hopeful for how the scientific ideas of the West would shape the future of law in Japan. He also told Asogi to learn all that he could in Britain, and fulfill his "mission". He again addressed Naruhodo, sensing "unusual potential" in him before delivering his verdict of "not guilty".

"Conclusion"[]

2:46 p.m.

Naruhodo, Asogi, and the Mikotobas celebrated the verdict in the defendants' antechamber. Professor Mikotoba told them that he had met Wilson in Britain, and they had worked at the same hospital. Asogi swore to him on his katana that he would learn all that he could on his own journey. As for Brett, Hosonaga revealed that the British foreign affairs ministry had demanded that she be sent to Shanghai, China, to be tried under a British consular court. Asogi was confused; the treaty should have rendered those courts void. Nevertheless, they could only hope that Brett would be brought to justice one day. As Hosonaga invited them all to La Carneval, Naruhodo accepted that he may never know why Brett had killed Wilson.

As everyone else left, Naruhodo commended Asogi for his skills, but the latter replied that the former had a natural talent for being a defence lawyer. To him, a lawyer's most crucial weapon was not any sort of skill or knowledge of the law, but their ability to make a choice about what to believe in, and holding strong in that belief against all odds, much like Naruhodo's trust in him. Asogi then wanted to ask Naruhodo for a favour, but was interrupted by Hosonaga, who informed them that he had arranged some rickshaws for them all to ride to La Carneval. The favour would have to wait, but little did Naruhodo know that it would change his life.

References to other cases[]

Notes[]

  • When Jezaille Brett is introduced, the judge exclaims that "no discussions take place without tea" and "it's always ladies first" in England. It is much later revealed in Twisted Karma and His Last Bow and The Resolve of Ryunosuke Naruhodo that not only was he one of the three exchange students who travelled to Britain ten years ago, but he also had experienced a trial in a British courtroom. In this context, this pair of exclamations does not make much sense for him to make seriously, and is primarily meant as a gag to illustrate how overly polite that he and Auchi are trying to be to Brett.
  • The Anglo-Japanese Treaty of Friendship and Navigation seems to be based on the 1854 Anglo-Japanese Friendship Treaty and the 1894 Anglo-Japanese Treaty of Commerce and Navigation. The latter is of particular importance as it entails the end of extraterritoriality for British subjects (hence Jezaille Brett being expected to be tried on Japanese soil after Naruhodo's trial) and the end of consular courts (hence the surprise that Brett would be tried in one).

Typos[]

  • In Jezaille Brett's testimony "The Victim's 'Death'," she says, "If there's some other way a man's life can been taken without leaving a trace, please, do show me."
  • When accusing Brett of poisoning Dr. Wilson, Ryunosuke says, "There's only person who could possibly have done it!" which should be "There's only one person who could possibly have done it!"
  • During Brett's confession, she admits that she hid a pistol under her skirt, to which Auchi responds, "U-Under you skirt...?"